At the upcoming Vancouver City Council meeting this Tuesday, July 21st, Councillor Adriane Carr (Green Party of Vancouver) will be tabling a motion that calls on Council to respond to the province's bi-partisan Special Committee on Local Election Spending Limits recommendations, released June 26, 2015, by requesting specific amendments to the Vancouver Charter to satisfy long-standing calls for substantial campaign finance limits in British Columbia's largest city.
Carr notes that the Special Committee's recommendations fail to address long-standing reforms requested by Councils, elector organizations and citizen groups for the past decade, including:
- Far from getting big money out of local politics, the Special Committee's recommended population-based spending limits formula would continue to allow an electoral organization running a full slate of candidates in Vancouver to spend near-record levels of more than $3 million in the next election.
- The Special Committee failed to recommend spending limits or reporting requirements for elector organizations in years between elections.
- The Special Committee's recommendations did not include any limits on the size or source of donations to candidates or elector organizations, despite unanimous resolutions of multiple Councils calling for a ban on corporate, union and out-of-province contributions.
Carr's motion (available here and copied below) responds to the Special Committee's recommendations by demonstrating their inadequacy in addressing the concerns that have been raised over the prevalence of big money in Vancouver politics, and their failure to incorporate any of the suggestions offered by Vancouver City Council, local elector organizations and citizens over the past several years, including during the latest round of consultations last spring.
For more background on this subject, please see also: Special Committee on Local Election Spending Limits fails to get big money out of civic politics in Vancouver (July 6, 2015).
FULL TEXT OF COUNCILLOR ADRIANE CARR'S MOTION TO BE TABLED JULY 21, 2015
Vancouver Response to Recommendations of the Special Committee on Local Election Expense Limits
1. The Final Report of British Columbia’s Special Committee on Local Elections Expense Limits was released on June 26, 2015, recommending per-capita-based local election expense limits that, based on the most recent census, would have allowed maximum spending of $2.9 million by an elector organization running a full slate of 27 candidates: an amount higher than the recordbreaking 2011 election spending of $2.2 million by VISION Vancouver and $2.4 million by the NPA that prompted Vancouver City Council’s repeated calls for limits to election spending;
2. All the other provinces in Canada referenced in the Special Committee’s report that base local election expense limits on a formula use a per elector formula;
3. Using a per elector rather than per capita formula would reduce election spending by an elector organization running a full slate of candidates by close to half a million dollars;
4. The reason given by the Special Committee for using a per capita formula is that “uniform, consistent, and centrally available lists of registered electors do not exist for all local governments in BC” (page 7 of the final report), yet the City of Vancouver has been choosing to use the British Columbia voters’ list for its elections;
5. The mandate of the Special Committee on Local Elections Expense Limits failed to include critical public policy questions related to election expense limits that have been raised in motions such as the motion passed on January 22, 2014, entitled “Response to Provincial Government on Municipal Campaign Finance Reform”, specifically: limits on individual donations, restrictions on sources of donations including a ban on corporate, union and out-of-country donations and annual reporting of revenues and expenses by elector organizations in non-election years;
6. Approximately $5.6 million was spent by all elector organizations in the 2014 Vancouver civic election and donations included an individual donation of $100,000 to one campaign and donations by one corporation totalling $360,000 to another campaign;
7. Unlike elector organizations in municipal elections, political parties in British Columbia are subject to annual financial report requirements;
8. Other Canadian jurisdictions are permitted to have more restrictive rules for campaign finances than Provincial regulations such as the City of Toronto which limits donations by an individual to a maximum of $5,000 combined, to all candidates and which also bans corporate and union donations to City Council races by limiting donations to individuals only;
9. The Legislative Assembly of British Columbia has regularly amended the Vancouver Charter, with previous amendments introduced by the 2014 Legislative Session: 2nd Session, 40th Parliament.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED
A. THAT the City of Vancouver verify with the Province of British Columbia that the provincial voters’ list which the City uses for its elections is “uniform, consistent, and centrally available”.
B. THAT Council instruct legal staff to draft recommendations to amend the Vancouver Charter to incorporate the following points and to have the City Manager forward these recommendations to the Legislative Assembly of British on behalf of City Council with a request that the changes be made and to take effect as soon as possible: